Comment: John Sturges' The Hallelujah
Trail was released in Region 1 on DVD with a fine soundtrack, but
a horrible non-anamorphic Transfer, which looked liked it was derived
from an old Laserdisc. The newer Region 2 release has a completely different
anamorphic transfer which doesn't have the overly strong colors of the
region 1 disc, but looks much more film-like and not like an old video
master. The framing is however problematic - the movie was shot in Ultra
Panavision with an original aspect ratio of 2.76:1. The american DVD has
an aspect ratio of 2.21:1, because it seems to have been transfered from
a spherical 70mm reduction of the 2.76 original, and the european DVD
seems to be transferred from a 35mm reduction print which was in better
shape, but has an aspect ratio of 2.35:1 and even less picture vertically.
But despite the cropping, the european disc clearly has the superior quality
and is the best way to watch the movie until a better transfer from the
70mm elements has been done.